Thursday, November 25, 2010

What is ‘Root Cause Analysis’ In ISO 9001 Standards?


What is ‘Root Cause Analysis’ In ISO 9001 Standards?
Suppose you come across a dandelion weed while in your garden. (If you have as little time in the garden as I do, at times you may find too many!) You pull off the head of the dandelion and all the leaves. There – you can’t see it any more.
The question is: does this fix the problem?
To illustrate, let me share some findings from an audit in a type of courier company. They collect & deliver items for their customers, and have contracts with large customers. If any customer complaints arise, the operations manager must respond in writing.
For audit, I chose a sample of complaints from the last 3 months and looked at what they’d done with them. Most complaints were for late/missed pick-ups or deliveries.
Some sample responses from the manager to the client:
A. This route has too many sites on it, we are looking at changing it.’
B. ‘The entry disappeared from the system. It was re-entered, and the pick-up went ahead the next day.’
C. ‘The driver was new and didn’t know. He has been spoken to.’ (A week later, the same driver missed another pick-up for the same customer.) ‘He no longer works for us.’
D. ‘I can only assume this happened while I was on leave, and the supervisor didn’t know he had to respond to your calls urgently.’

And my favourite E: ‘The driver was late because there were delays during the day.’
These responses are typical of just looking at symptoms: pulling off the dandelion leaves. That approach leaves the root of the problem still intact. Like the dandelion, you can pretty much bank on the fact that it’s going to come up again. And again. And again. Until you do something to find the real cause (or causes). That’s effective root cause analysis, because you get to the root: the real underlying cause.
For example: Why does a route have ‘too many sites’ on it? What does ‘looking at changing it’ mean? Has it been done? If it was changed, did the changes work? If not, when will it be done? How did that route get ‘too many sites’ on it? And what would stop that happening again, or on another route?
Consider the ‘new’ driver: Why didn’t he know what to do? Had he received the information he needed such as induction and training? If not, why not? Why is ‘speaking to’ a driver adequate to prevent recurrence? (it’s not) Has the company reviewed how it selects its drivers? Because the recurrence a week is a strong sign of inadequate cause analysis and ineffective corrective action.
Why Find the Root Cause?
Most organisations are busy and somewhat chaotic. Immediacy often rules. So there’s often a tendency to go for the quick fix – treat the symptom rather than the real, underlying cause. The driver is ‘spoken to’, the order ‘re-entered into the system’. But this almost guarantees the same or very similar situation will recur, and have to be dealt with again. And again.
When problems come up in your organisation – which they will – you can choose how to respond. You can look for someone to blame and stop at the symptom (‘the driver was new… the supervisor didn’t know… it disappeared from the system’). Quite apart from the damage it causes to personnel relations, this approach isn’t effective.
An organisation with an intelligent approach to quality knows the value of a systematic approach to problems, including root cause analysis. The best question is: What can we learn from this situation? And then: How can we apply that learning to improve?
When Should You Use Root Cause Analysis?
If you have or aspire to ISO 9001, you must have a systematic approach to problems: nonconformance, corrective and preventive action. Without it, you’ll find it hard to pick problems for root cause analysis, because they’re often distributed over time (so you don’t realize they recur), or happen to different people (so you don’t realise they recur in your organisation).
Good candidates for root cause analysis are the situations that recur most often, and use the most resources to rectify or those that cause the most damage when they do.
Remove the Root Cause or Not?
After you’ve identified the root cause/s, you have to decide if it’s worth removing the root cause or whether you continue to treat the symptoms. This isn’t always an easy decision.
It’s often relatively easy to estimate the cost of removing the root cause, but less easy to assess the cost of not doing so. Suppose, for example, a truck breakdown turns out to have been caused by ineffective maintenance by a supplier. And suppose that supplier costs $10,000 less per year than the other. Superficially, the cost vs savings looks good.
But suppose that also means a truck off the road for at least an extra 5 days a year – and your largest customer got so angry about one too many crucial but failed pick-ups that they don’t renew your contract. And tell everyone what an unreliable company you are.

What is ‘Root Cause Analysis’ In ISO 9001 Standards?


What is ‘Root Cause Analysis’ In ISO 9001 Standards?
Suppose you come across a dandelion weed while in your garden. (If you have as little time in the garden as I do, at times you may find too many!) You pull off the head of the dandelion and all the leaves. There – you can’t see it any more.
The question is: does this fix the problem?
To illustrate, let me share some findings from an audit in a type of courier company. They collect & deliver items for their customers, and have contracts with large customers. If any customer complaints arise, the operations manager must respond in writing.
For audit, I chose a sample of complaints from the last 3 months and looked at what they’d done with them. Most complaints were for late/missed pick-ups or deliveries.
Some sample responses from the manager to the client:
A. This route has too many sites on it, we are looking at changing it.’
B. ‘The entry disappeared from the system. It was re-entered, and the pick-up went ahead the next day.’
C. ‘The driver was new and didn’t know. He has been spoken to.’ (A week later, the same driver missed another pick-up for the same customer.) ‘He no longer works for us.’
D. ‘I can only assume this happened while I was on leave, and the supervisor didn’t know he had to respond to your calls urgently.’

And my favourite E: ‘The driver was late because there were delays during the day.’
These responses are typical of just looking at symptoms: pulling off the dandelion leaves. That approach leaves the root of the problem still intact. Like the dandelion, you can pretty much bank on the fact that it’s going to come up again. And again. And again. Until you do something to find the real cause (or causes). That’s effective root cause analysis, because you get to the root: the real underlying cause.
For example: Why does a route have ‘too many sites’ on it? What does ‘looking at changing it’ mean? Has it been done? If it was changed, did the changes work? If not, when will it be done? How did that route get ‘too many sites’ on it? And what would stop that happening again, or on another route?
Consider the ‘new’ driver: Why didn’t he know what to do? Had he received the information he needed such as induction and training? If not, why not? Why is ‘speaking to’ a driver adequate to prevent recurrence? (it’s not) Has the company reviewed how it selects its drivers? Because the recurrence a week is a strong sign of inadequate cause analysis and ineffective corrective action.
Why Find the Root Cause?
Most organisations are busy and somewhat chaotic. Immediacy often rules. So there’s often a tendency to go for the quick fix – treat the symptom rather than the real, underlying cause. The driver is ‘spoken to’, the order ‘re-entered into the system’. But this almost guarantees the same or very similar situation will recur, and have to be dealt with again. And again.
When problems come up in your organisation – which they will – you can choose how to respond. You can look for someone to blame and stop at the symptom (‘the driver was new… the supervisor didn’t know… it disappeared from the system’). Quite apart from the damage it causes to personnel relations, this approach isn’t effective.
An organisation with an intelligent approach to quality knows the value of a systematic approach to problems, including root cause analysis. The best question is: What can we learn from this situation? And then: How can we apply that learning to improve?
When Should You Use Root Cause Analysis?
If you have or aspire to ISO 9001, you must have a systematic approach to problems: nonconformance, corrective and preventive action. Without it, you’ll find it hard to pick problems for root cause analysis, because they’re often distributed over time (so you don’t realize they recur), or happen to different people (so you don’t realise they recur in your organisation).
Good candidates for root cause analysis are the situations that recur most often, and use the most resources to rectify or those that cause the most damage when they do.
Remove the Root Cause or Not?
After you’ve identified the root cause/s, you have to decide if it’s worth removing the root cause or whether you continue to treat the symptoms. This isn’t always an easy decision.
It’s often relatively easy to estimate the cost of removing the root cause, but less easy to assess the cost of not doing so. Suppose, for example, a truck breakdown turns out to have been caused by ineffective maintenance by a supplier. And suppose that supplier costs $10,000 less per year than the other. Superficially, the cost vs savings looks good.
But suppose that also means a truck off the road for at least an extra 5 days a year – and your largest customer got so angry about one too many crucial but failed pick-ups that they don’t renew your contract. And tell everyone what an unreliable company you are.

Certification Of ISO 14001

Certification Of ISO 14001

International Organization for Standardization (ISO) is functioning from Geneva in Switzerland as a worldwide federation of national standards organizations. The mission of ISO is to promote the development of standardization and related activities in the world with a view to facilitating the international exchange of goods and services, and to developing corporation in the spheres of intellectual, scientific, technological and economic activity. ISO’s works result in international agreements which are published as international agreements which are published as international standards.

ISO 9000

Previous version of ISO 9000 (1994) emphasize on documents and document control. But as per new standard the extent of documentation can differ from company to company in a simplified manner.

ISO 9000 system requires records at relevant stages which provide data for continual improvement and can be used for legacy as a data bank.

ISO 14000

ISO 14000, the environmental management system family of standards, was formally published by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) on September 2, 1996. ISO 14001 is the conformance standard within the ISO 14000 series. After extensive groundwork, the revised version of ISO 14001 was released on 15th of November 2004. ISO 14001:2004 will replace ISO 14001:1996 after a transition period of 18 months, ending on 14th May 2006, and will become the basis for the certification procedure for environmental management. All ISO 14001:1996 certificates will be rendered invalid on 15th May 2006

Since 1996 the ISO 14001 has formed the basis for structuring, implementation, review and further development of environmental management systems. It lays down the applicable demands for organizations of all kinds and sizes as well as for diverse geographical, cultural and social conditions. The overall objective is to promote environmental protection and the prevention of environmental stress in harmony with economic, social and political requirements.

OHSAS 18001 is an Occupation Health and Safety Assessment Series for health and safety management systems. It is intended to help an organizations to control occupational health and safety risks (OH&S). The importance of managing Occupational Health and Safety is recognized by all interested parties – employers, employees, customers, suppliers, insurers,shareholders, the community, contractors, and regulatory agencies. It enables an organization to control occupational health and safety risks risks and to improve performance.

Certification Of ISO 14001

Certification Of ISO 14001

International Organization for Standardization (ISO) is functioning from Geneva in Switzerland as a worldwide federation of national standards organizations. The mission of ISO is to promote the development of standardization and related activities in the world with a view to facilitating the international exchange of goods and services, and to developing corporation in the spheres of intellectual, scientific, technological and economic activity. ISO’s works result in international agreements which are published as international agreements which are published as international standards.

ISO 9000

Previous version of ISO 9000 (1994) emphasize on documents and document control. But as per new standard the extent of documentation can differ from company to company in a simplified manner.

ISO 9000 system requires records at relevant stages which provide data for continual improvement and can be used for legacy as a data bank.

ISO 14000

ISO 14000, the environmental management system family of standards, was formally published by the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) on September 2, 1996. ISO 14001 is the conformance standard within the ISO 14000 series. After extensive groundwork, the revised version of ISO 14001 was released on 15th of November 2004. ISO 14001:2004 will replace ISO 14001:1996 after a transition period of 18 months, ending on 14th May 2006, and will become the basis for the certification procedure for environmental management. All ISO 14001:1996 certificates will be rendered invalid on 15th May 2006

Since 1996 the ISO 14001 has formed the basis for structuring, implementation, review and further development of environmental management systems. It lays down the applicable demands for organizations of all kinds and sizes as well as for diverse geographical, cultural and social conditions. The overall objective is to promote environmental protection and the prevention of environmental stress in harmony with economic, social and political requirements.

OHSAS 18001 is an Occupation Health and Safety Assessment Series for health and safety management systems. It is intended to help an organizations to control occupational health and safety risks (OH&S). The importance of managing Occupational Health and Safety is recognized by all interested parties – employers, employees, customers, suppliers, insurers,shareholders, the community, contractors, and regulatory agencies. It enables an organization to control occupational health and safety risks risks and to improve performance.

ISO 9001 Standard Quality Manual Template


ISO 9001 Standard Quality Manual Template

The quality manual is the necessary cornerstone for any business venturing out on the ISO 9001:2008 accreditation route as it exhibits top management’s determination to managing an useful quality management system. The quality manual is a type of most essential document which provides the right impression to clients, staff, inspectors and all the parties interested in your company, about your company’s efforts to satisfy all their clientele’s needs. People through your company will relate to it whenever they prefer to find the big picture of the system, or exactly what guidelines have been organized. You can save your valuable time and hard earned money with the quality manual template we offer you. If you really compile the quality manual, you will easily comprehend and apply ISO 9001:2008, which is one of the best methods to do so.By reading by the needs one-by-one and assigning each prerequisite a specific document, process or technique that exists within your company, you will get that over half of the demands have already been resolved. Quality manual makes the relation, between the process and the documents, an official one. Format and content Write your quality manual to ensure that it works for you, for your company and also the manner you work, it is totally your selection however generally make sure that it supports your organisation’s targets. The quality manual should not contain any confidential or proprietary information as it should be readily available to third party auditors and customers. You should also ensure that a clear distinction is made between the contents of the quality manual and the procedures. The quality manual identifies the intention of top management for the operation of the quality management system, whilst the operations explain how these kind of purposes are integrated. There are three things that must be included in the quality manual:

1. The probability of the quality management system such as details of the validation of any exclusions

2. For quality management system, the procedures should be standard or should be mentioned in them

3. A explanation of the discussion between the procedures of the quality management system Who will use your Quality Manual and why?

In general, the clients and the prospective customers need it in order to know how your company system meets their requirements. If your quality manual includes two pages, it may not motivate trust that your system is strong enough to be an useful quality management system. Customers and Clients want assurance that you know how to plan, implement, and control the processes that affect their products or service delivery. The third party inspectors will b interested to know how your company meets their standard needs and also if perhaps the quality management system is useful in accomplishing your organization’s targets. Auditors will use the quality manual as a guide to help out discover and also form the purpose facts that they have to find in exhibition of your company’s compliance with the standard. Internal inspectors can review and inspect their own company for their needs rather than referring to standard documents from external sources. Management ought to be able to determine, from the manual, how the numerous processes and also systems have interaction, and at a high level what policies and methods have been established to maintain and control the processes and systems . The quality manual is usually presented to fresh recruits to familiarize themselves with the organization’s quality management system and also the manuals are often used as an in-house training resource. Most importantly, your quality manual ought to not sit on a dirty shelf or be hidden in an obscure position on the computer network; it is an active and powerful document that requires coverage in order for it to grow and also improve. Please click on the links below to learn more about Quality Manual Templates and view some free examples.